Wednesday, November 18, 2026

WHAT IS THE "PROMISED LAND"?

 

WHAT IS THE “PROMISED LAND”?

Christopher Nyerges  [www.SchoolofSelf-Reliance.com]




Today, I was treated to a lecture which compared two books, and two very similar concepts, with their many variants.

First was Manly P. Hall’s “Secret Destiny of America,” and the second was Harold Percival’s “Thinking and Destiny.” Both offer unique and original descriptions of what we might call “the Promised Land.”

As a child in  Catholic school, I learned about Moses wandering for 40 years in the desert with his people in search of the Promised Land.  But it seemed that, as far as the Church was concerned, I was never to see the Promised Land in my lifetime. It would be something that I would (hopefully) experience after I die. 

And over the decades, I became aware of many people who did not want  to wait until they died to experience their Promised Land.  Many cults have famously not wanted to wait til after death, and they tried to create utopias on earth, such as Hitler’s attempts to create a homeland for the so-called Aryan race, or Jonestown which ended in disaster, or India’s Bhagwan who tried to create Utopia in Oregon.    It could be argued that the Mormons are trying to create their own Promised Land in Utah, and that perhaps the Amish are already living in their Promised Land.

In Manly Hall’s book, he puts forth the proposition that, going back to the ancient Egyptians, many cultures have looked for, and planned for, this Heaven on Earth.  Manly Hall shares esoteric and marginal data going back centuries to suggest that “wise people” knew of North America and believed it would be the Utopian society one day.  He uses all sorts of “evidence,” including the vast use of symbolism by the early Masons, to convince his readers that the destiny of the United States was to become this  Promised Land. 

After he shares the scant data from Egypt and Greece and elsewhere from the ancient world, he comes to North America and says, Lo and Behold, there actually was such a society like that in North America.  He then describes the Mayan civilization and all its outstanding traits, including the fact that they apparently had no money, and that they largely worked for the common good.  Only after at least 500 years of this ideal society did it decline, and the worst of the Maya practices occurred.  Hall also points to the Iroquois Confederacy, a pact among  7 northeastern Tribes that lives to this day. From the Iroquois Confederacy, Ben Franklin and others saw key ideal elements in their government which were “borrowed” to create our Senate and Presidency. 

But  the key flaw, in my opinion, is Hall’s assertion that somehow North America was either decided upon, or divinely designated, to be this Promised Land.  What about the people already living here?  Of course, we know what happened as Europeans flooded in, some wanting a better life but many more just wanting something to take.  How can a Promised Land ever be based upon the death and destruction of another culture.

Hall was writing in the 1940s in idealistic and inspiring tones.  But did he miss the point of what it means to be in a Heaven, or a Promised Land?

I am reminded of the time when the zealots were hoping that Jesus would lead a revolution against the Romans, and he responded that his Kingdom was not of this world.  When asked when the Kingdom will come, Jesus replied that the Kingdom is at hand, here now, within, but that they could not see it.  Which leads us to the second book, “Thinking and Destiny.”

For the Promised Land, Percival uses  the term “Realm of Permanence.”  And to get to this Realm, one has to eventually leave the worldly path.  It is not a place to get to, but rather it is a state of being.  And you can’t force it.  Once you know you are ready to “go on the Way ,” you still have to fulfill all your responsibilities.  Percival says that if you are on this path, your worldly responsibilities gradually drop away.

Assuming you become world-weary and choose this path, what must one do? On   this point, Percival is very clear.  Honesty and truthfulness must be the foundation of your character.  One must have the unequivocal feeling and desire to see things as they are, so that preferences and prejudices do not lead you astray .  Ingratitude, malice, rancor, hatred, envy, anger, jealousy, meanness, greed, gloom, discontent, malice, and cruelty must all be strangers to you.  (Of course,  this is the 25-cent version of Percival’s thousand page book).

As I pondered the differences between the theses of Manly Hall and Harold Percival, I realized that Percival’s perspective made a lot more sense.  The Promised Land, Heaven, or the Realm of Permanence are not places that you go to. They are states of being.  They are what we become by our actions and our thinking.  Which brings to mind the hip saying of “Be Here Now,” or even Gandhi’s “Be the change that you want to see in the world.”

To me, reaching the so-called Promised Land is another way of describing “Enlightenment.”  You can travel everywhere you want, and perhaps there is nothing wrong with that, but it’s all about changing  yourself.

No comments: